| Name | Time | Sex | Age | Beer | Notes |
| 1. |
Tom "Spongeworthy" Hirt
| 14:41.0 | M | 29 | Coors Light, from can | Puked 10 yards past finish line |
| 2. | Kevin "Mulva" Cheddar | 14:51.0 | M | 32 | Coors Light, from can | 4 foot stocking cap slowed him down |
| 3. | Deb "Puffy Shirt" Hirt | 16:00.0 | F | 23 | Coors Light, from can | First female finisher; sister of winner |
| 4. |
David "I was in the pool!" Cheddar
| 17:45.0 | M | 31 | Miller Lite, from can | Wore bike helmet |
| 5. | Mark "Crazy Joe Devola" Jones | 17:51.0 | M | 25 | Coors Light, from can | Dressed as a friar |
| 6. |
Bonnie "Schmoopie" Reichardt
| 18:45.0 | F | 25 | Coors Light, from can | Penalty lap; puked during 4th lap through nose |
| 7. | Liz "Jean-Paul" Ernst | 24:20.0 | F | 23 | Coors Light, from can | Puked 4+ times after finishing |
| 8. |
Colin "Schmoopie" Barr
| 30:00.0 | M | 28 | Miller Lite, from can | Questionable beer drinking caught on tape |
| 9. |
Sara "Serenity now" Hirt
| 30:05.0 | F | 27 | Coors Light, from can | 2nd female to finish and not puke |
| 10. |
Cort "T-Bone" Sattler
| 31:45.0 | M | 30 | Miller Lite, from can | Penalty lap; spill with intent |
| 11. | Katie "Real and Spectacular" Leisner | 31:59.0 | F | 23 | Coors Light, from can | Penalty lap; puked at least 2 times |
| 12. | Mike "Airing of grievances" Linegang | 35:15.0 | M | 30 | Miller Lite, from can | Penalty lap; spill with intent |
| 13. | Betty Ann "Feats of Strength" Linegang | 36:00.0 | F | 33 | Miller Lite, from can | Penalty; spill with intent |
| 14. |
Rosie "Soup Nazi" Oliva
| 36:05.0 | F | 28 | Coors Light, from can | Penalty; spill with intent |
| 15. | Claire "Master of her domain" Liszkay | 38:15.0 | F | 23 | Miller Lite, from can | I feel good |
| 16. | Sarah "Jerk Store" Vecci | 38:51.0 | F | 24 | Coors Light, from can | Last place finisher! |
| 17. | Holly "Festivus" Sattler | DNF | F | 30 | N/A | Walked, helped officiate... currently pregnant |
| 18. | Nick "Fusilli Jerry" Fererri | DNF | M | 26 | Coors Light, from can | Herniated L4-5 disc in back, did have 3 extra beers, worked camcorder |
| 19. |
Andrew "Coco" Jamieson
| DNF | M | 28 | Coors Light, from can | Tore ACL bending over to pick up 1st beer |
| 20. | Dave "Manssiere" Martin | DNF | M | 30 | N/A | Unable to compete; helped officiate |
| 21. | Sheila "Man Hands" Martin | DNF | F | 30 | N/A | Officiated |
| 22. |
Scott "Poppie" Kulka
| DNF | M | 28 | N/A | Late arrival |
| 23. |
Jodi "Hoochie Mama" Kulka
| DNF | F | 28 | N/A | Late arrival, also pregnant |
| 24. |
Ben "Vegetable Lasanga" Penry
| DNF | M | 24 | N/A | Called arriving late biggest mistake of 05 |